Skip to content
The Stoa

Concept

Preferred and dispreferred indifferents

ἀδιάφορα· προηγμένα καὶ ἀποπροηγμέναadiaphora; proēgmena kai apoproēgmenaLatin: indifferentia; praeposita et reiecta

Health, wealth, reputation and their opposites are neither good nor bad, though some are naturally preferable to others.

About this idea · editorial

Only virtue is good and only vice is bad; everything else is indifferent. Life and death, health and sickness, wealth and poverty, fame and obscurity do not in themselves make anyone happy or unhappy, because they can be used well or badly.

Most Stoics nevertheless distinguished among indifferents. Some, like health and wealth, are preferred: it is natural and reasonable to select them, other things being equal. Others, like sickness and poverty, are dispreferred. Aristo of Chios rejected this distinction, holding that nothing between virtue and vice differed in value, and the orthodox school regarded his view as a mistake.

The distinction lets the Stoic act in the world, pursuing health or a fair outcome, while recognising that success or failure in these things does not touch what matters. See Lives 7.101–107.

Key passages

Goods comprise the virtues of prudence, justice, courage, temperance, and the rest; while the opposites of these are evils, namely, folly, injustice, and the rest. Neutral (neither good nor evil, that is) are all those things which neither benefit nor harm a man: such as life, health, pleasure, beauty, strength, wealth, fair fame and noble birth, and their opposites, death, disease, pain, ugliness, weakness, poverty, ignominy, low birth, and the like. This Hecato affirms in his De fine, book vii., and also Apollodorus in his Ethics. and Chrysippus. For, say they, such things (as life, health, and pleasure) are not in themselves goods, but are morally indifferent, though falling under the species or subdivision things preferred.

Diogenes Laërtius, Lives 7.102 · trans. R. D. Hicks (1925)

To benefit is to set in motion or sustain in accordance with virtue; whereas to harm is to set in motion or sustain in accordance with vice.

The term indifferent has two meanings: in the first it denotes the things which do not contribute either to happiness or to misery, as wealth, fame, health, strength, and the like; for it is possible to be happy without having these, although, if they are used in a certain way, such use of them tends to happiness or misery. In quite another sense those things are said to be indifferent which are without the power of stirring inclination or aversion; e.g. the fact that the number of hairs on one’s head is odd or even or whether you hold out your finger straight or bent. But it was not in this sense that the things mentioned above were termed indifferent, they being quite capable of exciting inclination or aversion.

Diogenes Laërtius, Lives 7.104 · trans. R. D. Hicks (1925)

All passages

86 passages in 11 works, found by: ἀδιάφορον, προηγμένον (Greek); indifferent things / neither good nor evil; praeposita / producta (Latin).

Meditations · 11

  • Meditations 2.11 — …men and bad, being things which make us neither better nor worse. Therefore they are neither good nor evil.
  • Meditations 3.11 — …natural law of fellowship with benevolence and justice. At the same time, however, in things indifferent I attempt to ascertain the value of each.
  • Meditations 4.12 — Greek text uses προηγμενα
  • Meditations 5.20 — Greek text uses αδιαφορων
  • Meditations 5.36 — …but rally to the fight as thou canst and as is due. If there be failure in things indifferent, think not there is any great harm done; for that is an evil habit. But as the greybeard…
Show 6 more
  • Meditations 6.32 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Meditations 6.45 — …word profitable be taken here in the common sense as said of things of the middle kind [neither good nor bad].
  • Meditations 7.31 — Greek text uses αδιαφορια
  • Meditations 8.56 — Greek text uses αδιαφορον
  • Meditations 11.10 — …their foundation: for justice will not be observed, if we either care for middle things [things indifferent], or are easily deceived and careless and changeable.
  • Meditations 11.16 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα

Discourses · 14

  • Discourses 1.9 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Discourses 1.20 — …know how careless you are with respect to good and evil, and how active with respect to things which are indifferent (neither good nor evil), observe how you feel with respect to being deprived of the…
  • Discourses 1.30 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Discourses 2.1 — Greek text uses αδιαφορητικον
  • Discourses 2.5 — Greek text uses αδιαφοροι
Show 9 more
  • Discourses 2.6 — Greek text uses αδιαφορον
  • Discourses 2.9 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Discourses 2.10 — …our will be habitually humble and faithful, or shameless and unfaithful, we regard as a thing indifferent, except only in the discussions of the schools. In that case, all the improvement we…
  • Discourses 2.13 — …happen?—Certainly he is not.— If then the things which are independent of the will are neither good nor bad, and all things which do depend on the will are within our power, and no man can either…
  • Discourses 2.16 — Where lies Good? In Choice. Where Evil? In Choice. Where neither Good nor Evil? In Things independent on Choice. What then? Doth any of us remember these Lessons out…
  • Discourses 2.19 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Discourses 2.22 — …also know how to love: but he who cannot distinguish good from bad, and things which are neither good nor bad from both, how can he possess the power of loving? To love then is only in the power of…
  • Discourses 3.3 — …the desire of the good, and to aversion from the evil; and with respect to that which is neither good nor bad it feels indifferent. For as the money-changer (banker) is not allowed to reject…
  • Discourses 4.1 — …base things were bad and honourable things were good, and that all other things were neither good nor bad, you would not even have approached this enquiry, nor have come near it; but immediately…

Enchiridion · 1

Moral Letters to Lucilius · 16

  • Letters 31.3 — …unless one has learned to despise toil and to reckon it among the things which are neither good nor bad. For it is not possible that a single thing should be bad at one time and good at…
  • Letters 66.14 — …circumstances, between which a great distinction can be drawn, belong to the category of indifferent things, but the virtue shown in each case is equal.
  • Letters 66.35 — …and evil; that which is foreign and external she regards as dross, and that which is neither good nor evil she judges as merely accessory, insignificant and trivial. For all her good resides in…
  • Letters 74.17 — Latin text uses producta
  • Letters 82.10 — Latin text uses indifferentia
Show 11 more

Lives of Eminent Philosophers, Book VII · 12

  • Lives 7.36 — Greek text uses αδιαφορον
  • Lives 7.37 — Greek text uses αδιαφοριαν
  • Lives 7.61 — Greek text uses αδιαφορα
  • Lives 7.92 — …counsel. And wisdom they define as the knowledge of things good and evil and of what is neither good nor evil; courage as knowledge of what we ought to choose, what we ought to beware of, and what…
  • Lives 7.101 — …of intensity. Of things that are, some, they say, are good, some are evil, and some neither good nor evil (that is, morally indifferent).
Show 7 more

On Ends, Book III · 7

Show 2 more

On Stoic Self-Contradictions · 6

Show 1 more
  • Plutarch, On Stoic Self-Contradictions 31 — …their demonstration. For they say, that what may be used both well and ill, the same is neither good nor bad; but fools make an ill use of riches, health, and strength of body; therefore none of…

Against the Stoics on Common Conceptions · 14

Show 9 more

On Providence · 1

  • On Providence 5 — …as the wise man, that is, to prove that the things which the herd covets and dreads are neither good nor bad in themselves. If, however, He only bestows them upon good men, it will be evident that…

On the Happy Life · 1

  • On the Happy Life 22 — …of our school, whose only good is virtue, can deny that even these matters which we call neither good nor bad have in themselves a certain value, and that some of them are preferable to others? to…

On Benefits · 1

  • On Benefits 1.6 — …from this, that while a benefit is necessarily good, yet that which is done or given is neither good nor bad. The spirit in which they are given can exalt small things, can glorify mean ones, and…
Esc

↑ ↓ to move · Enter to open