Concept
Good feelings
The rational counterparts of the passions that the wise person feels: joy, caution and wishing.
About this idea · editorial
The Stoic sage is not without emotion. In place of the passions, the Stoics described three eupatheiai, or good feelings: joy instead of pleasure, caution instead of fear and rational wishing instead of craving. There is no good counterpart to distress, because nothing truly bad is ever present to the wise.
These feelings rest on true judgements. Joy, for instance, is a reasonable elation at something genuinely good, such as one’s own virtue. Seneca writes of real joy as a serious, inward thing, quite different from cheerfulness. Diogenes Laërtius lists the good feelings and their subdivisions at Lives 7.116.
Key passages
Also they say that there are three emotional states which are good, namely, joy, caution, and wishing. Joy, the counterpart of pleasure, is rational elation; caution, the counterpart of fear, rational avoidance; for though the wise man will never feel fear, he will yet use caution. And they make wishing the counterpart of desire (or craving), inasmuch as it is rational appetency. And accordingly, as under the primary passions are classed certain others subordinate to them, so too is it with the primary eupathies or good emotional states. Thus under wishing they bring well-wishing or benevolence, friendliness, respect, affection; under caution, reverence and modesty; under joy, delight, mirth, cheerfulness.
All passages
11 passages in 2 works, found by: εὐπάθεια (Greek); joy + caution + wishing together.
Moral Letters to Lucilius · 10
- Letters 23.4 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 23.5 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 35.3 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 59.2 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 59.3 — Latin text uses gaudia
Show 5 more
- Letters 59.14 — Latin text uses gaudio
- Letters 59.17 — Latin text uses gaudia
- Letters 76.28 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 81.24 — Latin text uses gaudium
- Letters 98.1 — Latin text uses gaudium